Caffeine Intoxication, A legal defense?

A man kills his wife.

His reasoning, he had too much caffeine that day.

Sounds pretty ridiculous right? Well for defendant Woody Will Smith, a man facing life in prison for the death of his wife, this is his legal defense.

On the day he killed his wife, he claims he was hopped up on caffeine due to the consumption of coffee, diet pills and energy drinks and  the large amount of caffeine caused him to be too insane to have consciously and intentionally strangled his wife to death. He also alleged that he was suffering from chromic insomnia, and was worried about his wife leaving him, and on the day he killed his wife he was “in a daze.”

So does having too much caffeine have any legal basis? Surprisingly yes, it’s called caffeine intoxication.   A caffeine overdose is classified as consuming more then 300 milligrams of the substance.   Smith claims he consumed around 400 milligrams of caffeine that day; however, according to blood tests taken that day it was concluded that he was not as over-caffeinated as he claims.

What are the symptoms of caffeine intoxication? Well, mainly you can expect irregular heartbeats, jitters or nervousness, and even euphoria and muscle twitches. However, if you go way over the limit of ‘normal caffeine consumption’ more serious results can occur ranging from temporary insanity and mania to the breakdown of skeletal muscle tissue that causes kidney failure.

Regardless of the medical proof that Caffeine intoxication is an actual illness, it still seems like a pretty far stretch that caffeine was the reason Woody Will Smith killed his wife. However, there is actually precedent that this defense has worked. In 2009, Daniel Noble actually won a dismissal of charges for running down and injuring several pedestrians with his car due to the fact that he drank two large Starbucks coffee’s before the incident and was consider to be “caffeine intoxicated.”

So what do you think? Does caffeine intoxication sound like a viable defense strategy?

Read the full story here


Leave a comment

Filed under Murder

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s